How did it ever come to this? How? This is the perennial question in the minds of every Bangalorean and Chennaite. Have we stooped to such levels that the two states engaged in the Indian version of the ‘Destruction Derby’ to see who can cause more damage?
The answer is a sad yes. The two states which not a year ago showcased humanity and cooperation beyond levels during the Chennai floods are now engaged in a hate war so poisonous that I now wonder is this really what we all are underneath.
This is not a post to go into the details of which state should receive more water rightfully and whether the Supreme Court decision is right or wrong. I am not the judge of that nor will I ever be.
What I wanted to do was to highlight a few thoughts in my head which I felt I should share with you all
Stop the hatred towards languages
Both states were built solidly on a foundation of respect and tolerance towards people from different walks of life. Everyone was accepted warmly and given maximum support to live your life. The Cauvery issue, a feud which has meandered on for decades, is one that suddenly shatters this way of life and instills hatred among the people from both states.
Each state has their point of view and neither can be discounted. Like an argument between two friends, both will stand their ground claiming they are right. This is precisely that. The two friends in question are the respective governments. While it is important for citizens to have a view and be concerned about how the verdict will affect their daily lives, it is totally unacceptable for people to spread hatred and take matters into their own hands.
I request you to view the thread posted by the above twitter user. He sums up it brilliantly.
One need only look at the Facebook and Instagram accounts for numerous Karnataka and Tamil Nadu based troll accounts to know the message of hate and animosity that was being propagated.
There were numerous incidents of Kannadigas in TN and vice versa being targeted for merely talking the language they know. Some of these people are just honest people looking to go about their daily lives without disrupting anyone and they were mercilessly targeted for something the governments failed to do. Just what good does this do. Will beating up a Tamilian or a Kannadiga suddenly ensure that the verdict becomes favourable for both sides? Mind you, these are the same people who flocked to theatres when a Kannadiga turned Tamil super star released his move in July. These are the same people who were proud of the fact that a Kannada actor featured in a Tamil movie. That is what this relation is about. Respect and not hatred.
While these fringe elements engaged in the very act of ruining lives, there were numerous videos online which showed how the people from each state ensured that their friends from Karnataka or Tamil Nadu were safe and showed just how much respect existed between the two entities.
What was worse is when news channels attempted to reach out to the people in Bangalore to warn them about the dangers in different areas, all the people could think about was which language the reporter was reporting in.
Take a look at this live video posted by a reporter from Asianet Newsable (https://www.facebook.com/AsianetNewsable/videos/1200910476645555/)
To all those who asked the reporter to speak in Kannada, imagine if this was a reporter in Chennai and your friends/relatives are stuck there and she only speaks in Tamil, won’t you be restless because you don’t understand what she is saying? Won’t anxiety take over and wish that she spoke in a language you know? That’s precisely what she was doing. All they needed to do was be supportive or shut up. Some even had the cheek to write colourful comments such as ‘Cute Girl’, ‘Love you’ in the comments below.
Language isn’t the issue here.If that be the case then we would cease to be a country and the very fabric of diversity that holds this nation together would disappear.
You are neither Batman nor the Avengers to take matters into your own hands
The video of the 22-year old engineering student being beaten up by fringe elements in Bangalore was spread, quite frankly in an irresponsible manner, across the country. What people saw was the act and not the context behind it. Yes, you cannot physically assault a person because of what they wrote on social media. By that logic, half the comedians in the country would be the recipients of a Bruce Lee style beating and their videos posted on online portals.
There is a legal system in place in this country for precisely this reason. Fraught with corruption and loopholes it may be, but it is still a system to be adhered to. The fear of the legal system is the only reason why anarchy doesn’t rule the roost. The boy who posted the inappropriate comments on social media could have been reported to the police. It is upto them on how they punish him. Instead a bunch of goons go all Batman on him and administer a beating which sickened me personally. 8 grown men beating a boy and a video made of the same. And yet when a famous RJ in Bangalore tried pointing out that violence was never the solution, all he got was hostility in return. With people questioning his loyalty to the city to downright abuse, very few saw the larger point he was trying to make.
Can you imagine what the parents of the boy would have gone through? The same goes for the man in Tamil Nadu who was beaten. For all they know, he could have been the sole breadwinner. He might have a family that depends on his work.
The vandalizing of Woodlands hotel in Chennai, the stoning of trucks in Bangalore, the destruction of cars, bikes and not to mention 40 buses. Mind you, the owner of the buses lost assets running into crores. How is this going to solve the situation? Starting a fire to warm yourself in the cold is logical and solves a genuine problem. Destroying public property in the aim that this would reverse the decision is foolhardy and downright stupid. The people involved in this were a mix of anti-social elements, who are in hibernation for a better part of the year, and then resurface in the first sign of unrest, students, and professionals. Is this what both cities are made of? Two of India’s finest cities brimming with innovation, talent and the epicenter of education and knowledge in India reduced to a bunch of squabbling entities hell bent on destroying lives.
Farmers from both states, the ones who are directly impacted by this verdict have been shunted aside, and instead more attention in the media and other channels is given to the activities of these anti-social elements. Police men in Bangalore and Chennai had the added burden of safeguarding Tamilians and Kannadigas whilst maintaining order during the St. Mary’s feast and Bakrid festivities. If these so called crusaders of justice really had the best interests of the state at heart, they would not want to cause inconvenience to its people. Instead their only aim is to disrupt the peace in both states for gains that are more oriented towards ensuring politicians keep their vote base over the welfare of people.
Yes, there are problems no doubt. Yes it is a cause for protest. But not at the cost of causing fear amongst the public. Not at the cost of damaging public property. And certainly not at the cost of law and order in the state.
“Nothing gives one person so much advantage over another as to always remain cool and unruffled under all circumstances” – Thomas Jefferson. It is upto us to decide which person retains their cool and who doesn’t. Mind you, people depend on it!